General introduction
After second world war and the end of the 20th century were
marked by the liberalization and the opening of the economy by technological
developments and a strong growth of the international exchanges accompanied by
a progression of the investments abroad of the large companies.
This last tendency which is, amongst other things,
internationalization is essential as one of the strategies of gaining companies
to have a durable competing advantage.
Indeed, the importance of the advantages which
internationalization with the various speakers gets that it is the company, the
consumer, the country of origin or the host country make of this phenomenon the
strategic way of development the most adopted.
However, it is necessary to recall that during the Eighties,
these international exchanges knew a run up against evolution and the opening
to the exchanges continued to progress but at less intervals.
In this respect, the foreign direct investments represent the
channel privileged to extend the fields of internationalization, at least the
form of presence which comprises possibilities of maximum control is a means of
continuing the preexistent competing fight by other means.
In the case of Tunisia, this new policy of the investment is
materialized by the promulgation of the new code of incentives to the
investments (law 93-120 of December 27, 1993) which proposes to ensure the
sites coherence, safety and profitability.
The foreign investment in Tunisia profits from several
advantages of various natures which made our country an quasi-obligatory
crossroads for the North-South exchanges. So the encouragements granted to the
foreign investors increase the chances of entry and evolution of the
investments on the Tunisian market. Remain to know for the foreign partners if
their sizes, their experiments and their capacities of adaptation can their
make it possible or not to reach the first steps of success.
Within this framework our problems are integrated :
« which is the impact of the size and the experiment of the partners
on the choice of the mode of presence by IDE »?
In a first part we will try to determine within the framework
of the first chapter the phenomenon of internationalization ; its factors,
its advantages, its consequences as well as the adopted strategies, in the
second chapter we will be interested in the joint venture like form of
cooperation to include/understand its characteristics and its methods.
In one second part we choose with a statistical evaluation to
check the validity of our assumptions of research which is as follows :
Assumption 1 : The size of the partners has a
positive effect on the level of investment ;
Assumption 2 : The size of the
partners has a positive effect on the level of control ;
Assumption 3 : The experiment of
the partners has a positive effect on the level of investment ;
Assumption 4 : The experiment of
the partners has a positive effect on the level of control
The principal interest of this research is that it enables us
to better include/understand the behavior of the investors in the choice of the
various methods of joint venture.
Part 1 :
Theoretical part
Chapter I :
The internationalization of the companies
The great revolution of the last quarter century is that of
universalization. The latter is a phenomenon with multiple dimensions in the
middle which the multinationalisation of the companies is. The multinational
corporations contribute already by their internal exchanges to the third
international trade. Fusions and acquisitions, creations of companies abroad
explode the level of the foreign direct investments.
Inevitably the multinational corporations are an essential
element in the world trade.
For better including/understanding the phenomenon of the
multinationalisation it is necessary to define it: its factors, its objectives
and the consequences which result from this.
Section 1 :
Definition and factors of internationalization
1-definitions
The definitions of the multinational corporations are many and
nonconsensual. According to Andreff1(*), the reasons of this diversity are mainly of two
types : the origin of the definitions and the nature of the criteria
selected. First of all the definitions emanate at the same time from leaders,
international organizations and academics (economists, managers, lawyers).
Then, they rest on various criteria such as the extent of the activity (size of
the company), the existence of subsidiary companies abroad, the number of
countries of establishment, the number of paid nationality other than that of
the head office or the adopted organisational structure.
Vernon (1987)2(*) defines a multinational as a company of big size
having industrial subsidiary companies in at least six foreign countries. Later
Caves (1982)3(*) considers
that the multinational is that which controls and manages a production abroad
in at least two countries.
Hugonnier (1984-1997)4(*) considers that a company becomes multinational as from
the moment when it carries out direct investments abroad or engages in
activities of direct co-operation abroad.
Michalet (1985) and Andreff (1996)5(*) define the multinationals as
being specific companies of which the organisational strategies and structures
are conceived on a worldwide scale.
According to Desreumaux (1999)6(*), the multinational corporation functions as a
decentralized federation in which the operations abroad are managed like a
largely independent business portfolio. Research on the strategies of
internationalization generally related to multinational firms or big sizes. The
place that SME occupy on the international scene remains still marginal if one
compares their trade with those of the multinational firms, so much in volume
than in value.
For the leader of SME, to cross the borders implies increased
risks and investments. All SME inevitably do not may find it beneficial to
internationalize themselves.
On the other hand, all the leaders of SME must plan a durable
growth their businesses in a market which does not cease being
internationalized7(*).
2 them factors of
internationalization
With an aim of widening their economic activities the
companies seek first of all to extend their market beyond the national borders
by export.
Vis-a-vis the obstacles (such as the protectionist policies)
the firms, according to Mucchielli (1992)8(*), judged more effective to conquer the foreign markets
while settling on the spot. They thus invest abroad by creating new companies.
These direct investments abroad can be also carried out by fusion or
acquisition of already existing foreign companies.
The firms also delocalize themselves because the adaptation of
the product to the specific request of the market will be easier for a
subsidiary company than for the head office. The legal constraints (technical
or medical standards), of the characteristics of the request related on the
taste and the income could better be appreciated and satisfied by the
subsidiary companies on the spot.
The delocalization of the Fifties to 65 which was based on a
logic of market will leave room to a delocalization based on a logic of
production and reduction of the wages. In front of the increase in the
competition of years 65-75 the firms will seek to reduce their production
cost9(*).
Indeed, thanks to new technologies and progress of
telecommunication the firms can make burst their production process while
making carry out each elementary operation in the country where it is the least
expensive. These spare parts will be then transferred in one or more points
from assemblies often close to the place to marketing. This division of the
productive processes at the same time makes it possible to reduce the
production costs and to carry out tax avoidance. The firm profits from an
access privileged to factors or raw materials at weak prices, in particular of
the low wages of the labor of certain developing countries.
Section 2:
Advantages and consequences of internationalization
1 them advantages
The conjugation of the advantages of the firm, of the
advantages of the country and the strategic advantages plays a driving part in
the delocalization.
Competitive 1.1-advantages of the firms and
comparative advantages of the countries
The specific advantages of the firms are to be brought closer
the more general concept of competitive or competing advantages.
According to Mucchielli (1992)10(*), these advantages can be of two sources : those
which reduce the production costs and those which allow the differentiation of
the products.
According to Mucchielli (1985-1987) and To carry
(1990)11(*), the competing
advantages of the firms are generally generated by initial advantages of the
country of origin concerning its total technological level, the qualifications
of its labor, the competing structure of its economy and the importance of its
domestic demand.
The advantages of the localization, for their part, must be
included in the comparative advantages of the countries, widened to take into
account not only the comparative costs, but also the relative advantages of the
sizes and dynamic of the requests main road and foreign.
On a side, the firm offers products and asks for factors of
production to manufacture them; those must be able to be acquired at the
weakest cost so that it remains competitive. Other side, the country offers
factors of production through its equipments of factors and of their
productivity (quantity and quality of the factors), it also asks products via
the consumers (quantity and quality of the goods).
Strategic 1.2-advantages
The synthetic analysis puts, initially, in relation the
countries and firm but the sector and the nature of its market play an
important part. Insofar as the sector connects the firms between them, its
structural characteristics will influence the establishment and initially the
mode of establishment.
After Jacquemin (1989)12(*), the strategic co-operations or alliances between
firms must be analyzed by reinstating a dimension of industrial strategy in the
theory of the multinational firm.
Strategies of co-operation/competition in an environment where
the borders of the sectors, groups and firms, are moving, take the form of
races between the various competitors. This strategic race can be observed for
the R & D, the production, the marketing and the adoption of the technical
standards all along the production process. 13(*)
Among the various strategies, the firms can establish
agreements for the starting stages of research and then compete with themselves
without co-operation in the phases of development of the research which must
generate the product itself. The reason of this behavior is due to the fact
that the stage of fundamental research is rather of type public property,
whereas following stages concerning the acquisition of a specific
advantage.14(*)
2 them consequences
The multinationalisation presents generally positive
consequences.
2.1-on the country of origin
The investment abroad can be beneficial since it ensures of
the sources of provisioning lower cost what makes it possible to restore the
competitiveness of the end product or to ensure the survival of certain
segments of production. It rather involves a stronger foreign competition which
uses same technologies of production but is given weaker wage costs. The
industries based on labor are then condemned in the industrialized countries
because of their social development.
The transfer of the activities makes it possible each nation
to concentrate on the activities in which it has a relative advantage what
involves a rise in the level of real income of the population.
With regard to the use and the factor income of production,
the investment abroad generally tends to reduce the application for a job
little qualified but increases the application for a job more qualified.
2.2-on the host country
The firms bring new technologies in the receiving country what
makes increase its productivity and makes him expenditure of research.
The contributions of very qualified work can also allow a
transfer of knowledge by the training and the formation of labor with the
result that the general economic effectiveness should increase.
Indeed, the establishment of a new foreign firm makes it
possible the host country to see growing its revenues from taxes.
However, it should be noted that the foreign subsidiary
company profits from an access direct to knowledge of the firm mother, its
saving like at the financial markets room and international.
Admittedly, one cannot neglect the negative effects of the
multinationalisation on the country of origin or the host country and which can
be summarized in three risks :
- The divergence enters the interests of the established firm
and those of the nation.
- The widening of the social inequalities.
- The companies are only established to divert the tariff
barriers what calls into question the advantage of technology
transfer.15(*)
Section 3 :
Strategies of internationalization
With economic universalization and the construction of
integrated economic areas, the bringings together of companies (alliances,
acquisitions of a holding, acquisitions...) experience a development growing
since the beginning of the Eighties.
When a company wishes to be combined, it is confronted with
the choice of the form of the bringing together. This decision is all the more
important as many firms manage from now on wallets of alliances being composed
of a large variety of agreements.16(*)
The companies which tie successful alliances examine initially
the strategic importance of alliance before concluding the contract, must thus
be shown the good moment and be managed in an intelligent way to be a success
and to release from the value for the companies partners.17(*)
However, there are several access modes to the foreign
markets.
1 them strategies of opening to several
dimensions
According to Zmerli (1998)18(*), the choice of the modes of presence comprises a
number of major stakes of which it is advisable to hold account, before
beginning. It is on this basis of analysis that a broad choice of possibility
is offered. These various possibilities will make it possible to be directed
more easily towards the solutions best adapted to specificities of the local
contexts like the means and constraints specific to the company.
There are two strategies of presence, a contractual presence
and a presence by direct investments abroad.
1.1 them strategies of contractual
presence
to it frankness has
According to the F F F19(*), the franchising is defined as « a method
of collaboration enters a crossing company on the one hand, and one or more
franchized companies on the other hand ».
It implies for the crossing company :
it property of a corporate name, a commercial name, initials
and symbols, of a service or, trade mark, know-how placed at the disposal of
the franchized companies ;
- A bundle of commodities and/or services :
* Offered in an original and specific way ;
* Exploited obligatorily and completely, according to
beforehand tested uniform commercial techniques' and constantly developped at
the point and controlled.
The purpose of this collaboration is an accelerated
development of the contracting companies, by the common action resulting from
the conjunction of the men and the capital, while maintaining their
independence respective, within the framework of reciprocal exclusive dealing
agreements.
It implies a remuneration or an economic advantage acquired
with the franchiser, owner of the mark and know-how.20(*)
B it transfer of license
It consists in conceding temporarily or definitively with a
third, the right to manufacture a product finished until the moment when the
product falls into the public domain counters royalties or royalties.
Generally the international license includes a variety of
contractual arrangements by which the domesticated companies (licensers) make
available to the foreign companies (licensees) its intangible properties
(formulas, trade secrets, know-how, name of mark etc.)
According to Wirth (1992)21(*), when the domesticated company yields a license of
patent, mark and know-how, it must guarantee to the bachelor all documentation
necessary to the manufacture of its product, it must provide him a technical
aid and commercial and train its personnel to him to adapt it to the new
technology.
The foreign bachelor must, as for him, to respect a certain
number of engagements, among which :
- To exploit the license by guaranteeing a certain level of
quality ;
- To organize the marketing of the product under mark in the
territory which is given to him ;
- To respect the confidentiality of information which is
transmitted to him ;
The leaders can rationally choose this mode like first stage
of penetration only by comparing the hoped profitability of this form of
presence with the other modes.
c- Subcontracting
It is defined as being « the operation by which a
contractor entrusts, under its responsibility, with another person called
subcontractor, whole or part of the contract of company concluded with the
building owner »22(*)
Subcontracting is thus under company which is characterized by
the execution of a given work on the one hand, and the independence of the
contractor in the completion of the work which is entrusted to him or rather
the legal absence of subordination to the client on the other hand.
It is thus enough that the subcontractor is independent in the
choice of the means intended to carry out the assigned objectives and this, it
does not matter that the principal contractor has the capacity to organize the
operation or the building site in time.
According to Haehnsen (1996)23(*), the partnership is different from traditional
subcontracting by a relation of confidence and mutual training and because it
introduces a basic concept which is the division of information and the
profits.
According to Garrette and Dussauge (1995)24(*), the choice between
partnership and traditional subcontracting depend at the same time on the
nature of the projects to realize and the strategic options of the partners.
D them contracts of
management
According to Leershnyder (1982)25(*), it is a question of ensuring,
for one determined period, the management of a company lately created abroad.
This company can be ; that is to say a manufacturing unit which was the
supply object « product in hand » for example, that is to
say a service company.
The contracts of management are different from the frankness
because the investment is « put in management ». The
investor remains owner of the built good, the elected company assumes the
responsibility for current management. The contract of management is a form of
presence which makes it possible a company to carry out an investment in a
foreign country and to entrust current management of it to a local
company.26(*)
1.2 them strategies of presence per Direct
Investment abroad (I.D.E)
According to Wickham (1989)27(*), the direct investment abroad (IDE) constitutes the
ultimate phase which corresponds to an increase in the output abroad via a
subsidiary company conferring on the investor a right of glance on
management.
A foreign direct investment indicates an investment which aims
at acquiring a durable interest in a company exploited in a country other than
that of the investor, the goal of this last being to influence indeed the
business management.
Until the end of the Sixties, the IDE took primarily the shape
of subsidiary companies created, however, since first half of the Seventies and
with a top reached in the middle of the Eighties, acquisition-fusions took over
creation of site.
According to Joffre (1994)28(*), the current preference of the Western companies,
including companies beginners on an international level for this form of IDE,
is explained primarily by four reasons related on the speed, the risk, the
undercapitalization of the target companies and finally to the need for
circumventing important barriers at the entry.
Bouyeure (1993)29(*) class the reasons which explain the growth of the
direct investment according to three logics :
- An industrial logic : seek the least expensive factors
of production ;
- A logic of market : easier access to the customer and
skirting of the barriers at the entry of the market ;
- A logic of company as an organization made up of resources
and more or less transmissible know-how.
2- The research of the co-operation
In this increasingly competing international environment, it
becomes necessary to the companies to identify their weak points know-how
competences in order to fill them as fast as possible. The fastest means to
cure it consists in seeking strategic alliances.
According to Folta (1998)30(*), economic diversification can lead an actor to invest
in an activity and competences different, distant from its field of origin.
This « technological distance » the uncertainty accentuates
with which a company is confronted.
The co-operation makes it possible to increase the resources
of the partners by the pooling of complementary competences and especially it
makes it possible to reduce the constraints of size and of uncertainty, it is
for that it became a better solution for the firms.
2.1-reports
To start it is advisable to answer this essential
question : what we call partnership relation ?
Alliances are a particular form of inter-organisational
relations in which competitors concert their actions on whole or part of their
activity.
In this research, alliances will be defined as concerted
projects which result from a choice on behalf of the various parts, desire to
converge towards common objectives or objectives for which an alliance is
necessary. Alliance is a succession of choice and process, it implies the
adaptation and the training of the men. The total principle of the partnership
relations rests on a task sharing, responsibilities and can cover all the
industrial process, design with the distribution of the product.
These strategic alliances combine competition and
co-operation, which makes their management delicate from the point of view of
the actors, the cultures and the potentially different individual interests.
This delicate management leads us to want to determine invariants of management
in the middle of this permanent instability.
The increase in trade on a world level, the need to offer
products, know-how always more innovating, train the leaders of the companies
of industry and the services to implement operating modes requiring an
operation in co-operation, network, alliance between firms.
2.2-Pourquoi to tie a
co-operation ?
Under the pressure of the crisis, a great number of companies
seek new axes of growth, generally within the framework of existing activities,
but also by increasing their economic performance and their flexibility by the
development of a strategy of externalisation.
The externalisation, in its current meaning, concerns the
concept of « the outsourcing » (subcontracting) or of
« Make gold Buy » (To make or Make-Make). It is a question
for the company of sub-contracting activities related to the process, even
directly of the parts of this process31(*).
This externalisation seems a new strategic dimension of the
company by a centering on the trade (S) basic which it controls. It appears as
a all the more interesting solution as the markets are
« turbulent » and that a reduction of uncertainty is
essential. The objective being to reinforce well the fields of expertise on the
company.
A research carried out by Wacheux (1993)32(*) provides three conclusions
partial on the situations of partnership relations :
- This form will develop under the pressure and the
constraints of the environment. If the company does not want to be reactive but
pro-active, the control of its environment becomes a dominating objective.
them analyzes are often based on concepts of the industrial
economy, economy of scale, phenomena of training, access to the markets,
integration. In addition, the co-operation is a problem of general direction
(level decisional and implemented).
- Taking into account the multiplicity of the actors and the
shared responsabilities, the models of management
« traditional » (system of direction, of information) do
not allow a priori an effective and efficient management.
Generally a company cooperates for :
- To reach new markets ;
- To open with the international one ;
- To develop commercial synergies on the basis of technical
complementarity ;
- To start a strategy of diversification ;
- To design and manufacture clean products ;
- To share a engineering and design department, a service R
& D.
2.3 it co-operation : Risky strategy or
gaining bet ?
According to Dussauge and Garrette (1997)33(*), the reasons for which the
companies tie co-operations divergent. The results obtained can not be those
awaited at the beginning by the contracting parts. So that a co-operation
succeeds, it is necessary for very that the companies partners defined their
strategy clearly.
The companies which tie successful co-operations examine
initially the strategic importance of the co-operation before concluding the
contract. They thus determine the way in which the co-operation is integrated
into the strategy of the company, in order to evaluate its performance of
it.
The operational persons in charge consider that the
co-operation is a success while being based on short-term criteria : the
success of the product, the impact on the costs, the effectiveness of work
completed jointly... But, it is necessary that the leaders of the companies
partners anticipate the long-term consequences of the co-operation on the
strategy of the company.
A strategy of partnership must have, according to Gomes-
Casseres (2001)34(*), four
elements to be coherent :
(1) - a marketing strategy reflecting the logic and the design
of the co-operation ;
(2) - a dynamic vision to manage each one of these
co-operations ;
(3) - a wallet of co-operations making possible the
coordination of these co-operations ;
(4) - an internal infrastructure optimizing the value of
collaboration.
The co-operations must thus be shown the good moment and be
managed
intelligent manner to be a success and to release from the
value for the companies partners. In the contrary case they will be very
expensive.
2.4 it Joint venture : a rational
choice !
The joint venture makes it possible to organize durable
relations in certain cases :
- to ensure the safety of control on technology : instead
of yielding a license, it can be recommended to take part in the capital of the
bachelor. This last is generally laid out to accept, because that facilitates
its financing, but also guarantees the access to know-how. The donor of license
can ensure a better control of its technology, to influence the strategy of its
bachelor, to observe his behavior as regards financing, R & D.
it joint venture can ensure of the possibilities of
subcontracting ;
it co-operation also moderates the behaviors of competition,
in particular between head offices ;
- to facilitate the relations of purchases and sales
reciprocal. The bonds create by the joint venture reduce the problem of fixing
of the delivery prices, in particular when there is not price of reference of
the market for the supplies.
The regular access to the supplies raw materials can be a
particular case of this strategy :
- agreement on the market : the joint venture can also
have for objective to harmonize the behaviors of competition of the head
offices.
- technical guarantee : the suppliers of technology take
sometimes a participation at their taker of license. 35(*)
Chapter II :
The Joint Venture : a form of cooperation
The world economy knows a perpetual change of structures, in
particular related on technical progress and the increasing globalisation of
the markets. That presents at the companies a challenge in all the fields
(technological, marketing, management, finances), challenge which they cannot
assume separately. The co-operation between the companies becomes an essential
solution.
The joint venture, a form of cooperation, is a passage obliged
in very firm countries which impose it legally and which prohibit the creation
of companies held with hundred percent by foreigners.
The creation of a joint subsidiary (joined venture) with local
companies is also desirable to penetrate durably and effectively certain
markets characterized by legislations, administrative constraints, cultural or
commercial differences, distribution networks,... which make them too
complex.
Section 1 :
Definition and characteristic of the joint venture
1-definitions
The definitions relating to the joint ventures, proposed in
the economic literature are multiple. We quote some:
« At least two sovereign companies, not belonging to
the same group, are intended to work towards a joint end in a specified space,
sharing or exchange resources to obtain advantageous results, while remaining
independent apart from alliance. This one takes form through the installation
of a distinct joint organisational entity.
On the other hand, the acquisition of a company by another,
the unilateral grant of a license, research under contract or total fusion are
operations which do not answer the definition suggested. »36(*)
« The joint venture implies an association with an
external industrial partner and relates to a jointly determined project ;
it comprises the pooling of means and risk. Its character is contractual :
even if it joint venture needs a support, in the form of a legal entity, it
« contract » (agreement of the parts) overrides
« structure » (legal entity control by the company law). It
is one « marriage » which implies, in theory, an equal
access to the decisions, independently of the respective contributions of the
partners : the joint venture is founded on the principle of parity. The
cohesion and the solidity of the business resident, ultimately, in balance
resulting from mutual interest, in perfectly definite reports/ratios of
complementarities. »37(*)
« Entities which play a full part on the market and
are held or controlled by two people at least who are not ordinary investors
and are not either under common control. »38(*)
Thus, it joint venture is the result of an association between
two or several independent economic entities, but which do not give up their
independence because of agreement.
The partners take part in the management of the firm and
contribute significantly to the decisions, by their voting rights.
2-characteristics of the joint
venture
Historical 2-1-outline
The first forms of cooperation between firms were primarily
joint ventures (JV). They are subsidiary companies create in target countries
by multinationals (generally American) which seek to penetrate in a new
geographical area. The principle of the joint venture consists in dividing the
capital of the subsidiary company with a partner
« indigenous ». The activity of the company common and
normally limited to the marketing and possibly, the manufacture of the products
of the multinational in the host country.
This form of agreement between firms progressed quickly
towards a new type of co-operation, whose weights and implications strategic
for the companies concerned exceeded those of the joint traditional ventures by
far. Strategic alliances had been born.
ventures and mutinationalisation
join
If one seeks to include/understand how the real activities of
the international joint-ventures evolved/moved, one notes a fundamental change
since 1975. As of this time alliances of a new type, near to the current
strategic partnerships, appear among the joint traditional ventures. Indeed,
the activity of certain multinational firms is not limited any more to local
marketing of products already developed and manufactured by the American head
office ; she extends herself with the development of new products and
export towards new countries.
Thus, it clearly appears that the joint international ventures
are released gradually from the traditional model, which made a simple mode of
export of it, to evolve to more strategic autonomy, to even compete with the
activities of the head office. One thus sees appearing, through the evolution
of the joint ventures of multinationalisation, the current phenomenon of
alliance strategic. However, that does not mean that the traditional ones
joined ventures of international expansion are dedicated to disappear. On the
contrary, the multinational groups continue to create some, in particular in
the countries in the process of development and the countries of Eastern Europe
where the legislation imposes that a certain percentage of the capital of the
companies is held by local shareholders39(*).
B-joint ventures and
competition
Whereas the initial objective of the studies on the joint
international ventures was to include/understand the various modes of
multinationalisation of the companies, the aim of research on the joint
ventures between firms of the same country is in general to evaluate the
anti-competitive effects of them.
The majority of the studies carried out in the United States
in years 1960 and 1970 tend to show that the agreements between American firms
are concluded with an aim of collusion and have anti-competing effects. It
appears besides that, in the majority of the cases, the joint ventures
associate concurrent firms between them, which seems well to prove their
collusif character.
However, towards the end of 1970, of the radically different
analyzes start to appear. Certain authors start to plead in favor of alliances
by showing that those can meet perfectly legitimate aims, going in the
direction of economic progress. Indeed, of many joint ventures are justified by
the will to acquire and combine know-how, which makes it possible to innovate
and better to satisfy the customers. By tying alliances, the companies do not
aim thus systematically first to increase the prices, to carry out immediate
profits or to improve their safety, they rather seek an alternative to research
and development (R & D) intern40(*).
2 - 2 them reasons to be
There is a multitude of reasons which justify companies to be
joined in order to create a joint subsidiary. The principal ones are generally
to exert on a common basis of the activities of production or distribution and
sale of products.
to it universalization has
According to Garrette and Dussauge (1995)41(*), the universalization of the
economy (or globalisation) is general and occurs in all the activities.
Information technologies (data-processing, telecommunications, telefax...)
enormously evolved/moved, thus facilitating the international communications
within the same company. It is thus from now on possible for the companies to
make work together teams located on all the continents and to reach all kinds
of technical resources world-wide. In addition, one attends a certain
standardization of the ways of life and behaviors of consumption, especially in
the three most developed zones world : The United States, Europe and
Japan.
B-acceleration of the technological
change
The speed of the changes does not make it possible to remain
in contact with all the innovations.
The company must concentrate on its activity and guarantee the
access to other essential fields using co-operations between firms.
In the sectors where technology is an important source of
competing advantages, it is not possible any more with the companies to assume
only the expenditure in research and development, nor to develop only the whole
of competences necessary to carry out a perfectly autonomous strategy. The
prospects for research are more numerous and of this fact more expensive
whereas the results become more random. The importance of the resources to be
invested as well as the complexity of technologies to be developed encourage
the companies to be combined, in order to combine varied and complementary
competences.
The joint ventures thus allow, by distributing work of R &
D between partners, to multiply the explored tracks, to share the costs and to
combine competences42(*).
C them obstacles with the
trade
The variations of exchange, diversities of national conditions
and the obstacles tariff and non-tariff always persistent oblige to set up
international structures pressed on partners who have an experiment and
contacts in the community of businesses and near the local authorities43(*).
2-3-advantages and disadvantages
Multiple advantages and disadvantages are related to the
choice of the joint venture like form of cooperation
A-advantages
The joint creation of a subsidiary company can have the
following advantages :
- Easier Penetration of the markets and more rapid for a
company limited in financial and human resource. Indeed, it can lay out of the
distribution systems already well established locally its partner, which
enables him to carry out a higher volume of sales in less time ;
- Reduction in the financial risks and the costs which are
theoretically shared between the partners. The joint venture allows certain
companies thus, thanks to the pooling of means, to finance projects which
differently would have been inaccessible ;
- Reduction in the commercial risk because the company can
profit from the experiment of the market (culture, regulations, contacts...)
and of competences of management of its local partner. The exporter is
familiarized and adapted consequently more easily to the conditions and the
specific needs for the foreign market ;
- Naturalization of the products. The joint venture not being
perceived like a foreign company, it makes it possible to establish better
relationships to the local government and the trade unions and thus to simplify
the administrative negotiations and formalities ;
it flexibility of organization of the joint venture ;
it tax flexibility related to the choice of the host country
of the joint company ;
- The independence and dynamism of management related to a
specific entity ;
it responsibility limited for the partners ;
- The granting of an ideal structure for creation of new
technologies jointly.
B-disadvantages
The company is exposed to a certain number of risks and
disadvantages when it chooses the creation of a joint subsidiary44(*) :
them potential benefit are less because they must be
divided ;
them costs of creation and, the échant case, of
winding-up of the company are rather important. In addition to the financial
investment, the creation of a joint venture requires an investment in time and
energy much more important than the other forms of partnerships ;
it formalism of the structure is higher than in other forms of
partnership. The legal assembly is very delicate to set up ;
- Risk of disagreement in connection with the distribution of
the dividends. The evaluation of the contributions of each partner, considering
their at the same time material or intellectual nature, is a complex and
delicate stage ;
- Risk of disagreement on managerial philosophies to apply
(strategy, staff management, political marketing, research and
development,...) ;
- Risk of conflict of interest ;
- Risk of lack of front communication, during and after the
formation of the joint venture ;
- Risk to affect the operations on other markets. If the
company wanted to create a local structure in a third country where the joint
venture is active commercially, it then becomes a potential competitor of the
joint venture whereas it is still partner ;
- In addition to the advantage which it brings to the
shareholders, the responsibility limited to the authorized capital limits the
guarantee brought to the thirds.
Section 2 :
Degree of internationalization
The joint ventures are strategies concerted in the form of a
joint undertaking. However, the partners of a joint venture prefer to limit
their engagement and their financial risk by choosing an adequate form compared
to their capacities.
1- Methods of establishment
After having decided to create or develop a joint subsidiary,
the company must choose a form of participation. The creation of subsidiary
companies can take varied forms.
The majority of the multinationals choose, at the beginning of
their internationalization, to penetrate in a local company with an aim of
better knowing the market, waitings of the consumers, the practices, the
competitors. This phase if it leads to attractive prospects, the persons in
charge cause a very important new issue of capital and since the local capital
is very insufficient, the multinational takes the control of the company in
question. This step reflects the importance of the distribution of the capital
since it determines the decision-making powers between the partners.
According to Wirth (1992)45(*), the idea of an equal distribution with 50-50 is
potentially rich in insoluble blockings. The parity thus is seldom chosen,
except in the case where, to avoid the charge of agreement, one would accept
the risk of blocking to show the independence of the subsidiary company towards
his head offices.
The most frequent situation is thus that in which a partner
holds the decisive majority. In practice one finds the alternative
following :
it absolute majority : the contractor must hold the bar
in hands well. What supposes the desire to name the brains trust or, at least,
to acquire the majority there. The disadvantage lies in the load increased in
financing, risk and monitoring.
it significant minority : this participation shows the
desire clearly to limit the risk and the monitoring, n the other hand of a less
influence.
From another point of view the minority investment can very
effectively prepare the massive entry on a local market. A small starting
company will make it possible to create of any part a great modern
manufacturing unit realizing of the larger or more frequent investments.
2 it level of investment and control per mode of
joint venture
Eleven notes of the range
Coût de transaction
Coût de contrôle
Degré d'internalisation
Subsidiary company 100%
Majority joint-venture
Joint-venture 50-50
Minority joint-venture
Concession of resource
License
Contract of offer
Contract engineering department
Machine turn-key
Free exchange
Source : Economy and
Industry, quarterly letter of the Saint-Gobain Company, n°68, December
1992, quoted by Joffre P (1994) : « To include/understand
the universalization of the company » Economica Edition
The joint majority ventures 50-50et seem to have the favor of
certain companies of the sectors of high technologies ; it is indeed in
these fields that the sensitivity of the companies to the rise of the costs of
coordination and control is strongest.
The search for solutions bringing a compromise between a
relative internalisation and less and/or shared costs of control is thus active
in these companies.
Moreover if one practical proves to be effective and that
industry is competitive one would have to expect that it is adopted by the
other surviving firms in this industry.
In the literature on the modes of entry it appears that the
firms exert more control when the volume of patents increases. The expenditure
in R & D makes increase wide license and still of advantage the wide one of
the investments (Davidson and Mc Fetridge)46(*)
Cheaper and less risked, the joint ventures flower like new
notes of the range of the modes of presence abroad. Caused by the host
countries of the investment or chosen by the Co-investors, the joint ventures
are not defined only negatively (less expensive and less risky) but also
positively as support having a multiplier effect of technological, industrial
and commercial know-how. In addition, they preserve a certain control of the
company which invests even if this last is attenuated by the presence of one or
more partners. Shared control is in any case a less mal.Section47(*) 3: Specific factors of the
joint ventures
The choice of a particular mode of presence is related to a
great number of various factors. It varies according to characteristics' of the
product such as its degree of differentiation, its importance, its age and
technology concerned.
It could depend on certain characteristics of the firm such as
its size, its resources, its degree of diversification and its policy.
Finally, the choice of the mode of presence can be determined
by external environmental factors ; such as the restriction on the free
exchange and the investment imposed by the country host, size of the market of
the country host and his geographical and cultural distance.
Section 3 :
Specific factors of joints ventures
This study will relate to two factors which are the size and
the experiment to try to determine their impact on the choice of the mode of
presence abroad.
1 cuts it
1.1 cuts it partners
According to the article of Hemant (2000)48(*), the research made on this
variable shows that the size of the firms which take part in a joint venture
has a great influence on the performance of the operation of the latter. It is
obvious that the costs projected to ensure the performance vary from large with
a small company.
According to Agarwal and Ramazwami (1992)49(*), the modes of investment would
be preferred by the firms which are larger and have more multinational
experience and in countries which are perceived like having a potential of
higher market, therefore, if the two factors are high the companies have a
preference for the modes of investment, if not they prefer not to engage.
These same authors show in their study the preference of the
great multinationals to choose the investment like mode of entry in the markets
with low potential. Indeed they noted that the small firms having limited
multinational experience prefer to enter from the markets perceived like having
a potential raised through the joint venture. That indicates that the TOKEN
ENTRIES E, less than the tested multinationals have needs to supplement their
requirements in resources with an aim of serving a potentially gravitational
foreign market.
Moreover, the resources are an explanatory factor among
others. They are not sufficient to explain the choice of each partner as
regards mode of presence. The resources themselves do not constitute a mobile,
they must be accompanied by the will to engage them with the development of a
foreign market.
High resources made it possible to the decision makers to
select a mode of entry for the target country among a broad range of
alternatives that the decision makers to scanty means. This fact a company with
raised resources, taking into account its size, is more likely to choose modes
of entry intégratifs.
1.2 cuts it market
The size present and projected market of the target country is
of an important influence on the choice of the mode of presence.
According to Davidson and Mc Fetridge (1985)50(*), the size and the maturity of
the market such as they are measured are not significant factors in the choice
between the licencing and the direct investment.
Agrawal and Ramaswani51(*) noted that the firms preferred to enter the markets
with more potential by using modes of investment. They tend to avoid the
markets who have a risk of raised investment, while only choosing to export at
the markets who have a high contractual risk, that nevertheless they could
invest in markets relative with low potential if their strategic objectives
dictates it.
Anderson E & Gatignon H (1986)52(*) consider like starting
postulate that the market to be penetrated has at least the potential to cover
the expenses of a mode of entry with high control. If it is not the case, a
high control cannot be considered.
An article emitted by Haiyang and Michael (2002)53(*) shows that :
cut it foreign market influences the decision of the choice of
the mode of presence ;
- When the size of the market increases, the benefit of
internationalization will increase ;
it fixing of the expenditure of internationalization can
separate from one with dimensions to another the width of the market what will
bring the benefit connected to the investment to increase highest possible.
Haiygang and Michael (2002) established the following assumptions :
- Assumption 1 : The size of the
partners has a positive effect on the level of investment ;
- Assumption 2 : The size of the
partners has a positive effect on the level of control.
2- The experiment
2.1-L' international experiment
It is the degree of engagement of a company in an
international activity which is reflected in the role granted to the foreign
markets in the total strategy, the statute of the international organization,
and the attitude of the managers. For the majority of the companies,
international engagement increases as the international experiment is formed
over a long period. Success in the foreign countries would encourage
international engagement, which would generate even more experiment. 54(*)
According to Koenig (1994)55(*) the experiment comes from :
it development of the aptitude as regards preparation of the
negotiations, research of information necessary and the exploitation of various
methods of outcome of conflicts ;
it contribution in the improvement of the technologies
acquired in the direction of a better response to the problems of the local
environment ;
it circulation of the ideas and the diffusion of the practices
constitutive of new competences ;
The experimental knowledge- the accumulation of knowledge of
the firm on foreign specific markets is a critical resource seen that even if
it is necessary to operate in any market it is not easily acquired.
In the first stages the firm should learn how on the local
conditions in order to reduce its dependence of the local organization then, it
would move towards the distant countries after having established a presence in
closer countries.
The firms at the time of the first international stages of the
expansion, prefer the countries by far culturally and geographically close
relations, and if it meets cultural barriers when it extends on the
international level it must learn from its last experiment.
When a firm begins a new entry profits more of the experiments
passed with the expansion in the same country, compared with a less extension
of the preceding experiments in the area which is closer to the country of
origin, this beneficial effect of the experiments is due to the training on
common cultural characteristics. 56(*)
2.2 it role of the experiment in the choice of the
mode of presence
According to Gatignon and Anderson57(*), the FMN choose the subsidiary
companies integrated into hundred percent as the cumulative experiment
(measured by the number of foreign markets penetrated on this date) increases.
Of the same Davidson notes as the aggregate experiment (measured by the number
of foreign markets), as well as an industrial experiment in the country host
increase the preference of the company to choose the subsidiary companies at
100%.
The theoretical explanation for a positive relation between
the experiment and the degree of control is focused on uncertainty. The the
least tested firms perceive a considerable uncertainty, an exaggerated risk and
underestimated incomes and avoid, consequently, engaging of the important
resources and assuming control.
Other authors suggest a negative relation between the
international experiment and the desire of control. Daniels et al.58(*), observed a tendency among the
companies in addition to-mother which start by investing in a total control and
end up dividing it as soon as the operation is established. The relevant
question to be posed would be to know if the experiment has a positive,
negative or null effect on the degree of investment and the degree of control
wished by the firm.
Two assumptions are to be checked :
- Assumption 3 : The experiment
of the partners has a positive effect on the level of investment ;
- Assumption 4 : The experiment
of the partners has a positive effect on the level of control.
Part 2 :
Empirical part
Chapter I :
Methodology of research
In this part of the study, we will try to expose the procedure
which we adopted in order to delimit the empirical framework. Indeed, a
scientific approach implies the search for information. And this of which the
objective to allow an improvement of the decision.
The methodology of research in marketing revolves primarily
around five axes which are ;
(1) - Identification and operationalisation of the problem
(2) - Framework of research
(3) - Data-gathering
(4) - Analysis of the data
(5) - Conclusion
Section 1 :
Identification and operationalisation of the
problem
1-recall of the problems
This study aims to determine the factors which influence the
choice of the mode of presence by the direct investment abroad in Tunisia, and
more exactly, the factors « CUT » and
« EXPERIMENT » which has a direct impact on the choice
between the various forms of IDE ; with knowknowing ;
- Minority Partnership : lower than 50% (the share of the
foreign partner is lower than 50%) ;
- Equitable Partnership : « 50/50 »
between the partners
- Majority Partnership : superior with 50% (the share of
the foreign partner is higher than 50%)
- Plate venture
« creation/acquisition » (the share of the foreign
partner is equal to 100%)
The diagram hereafter shows the step well that we followed.
Choix de développement par l'internationalisation
Choix de la Tunisie comme pays hôte pour y investir
Autres pays
Existe-il un marché potentiel qui intéresse
l'entreprise ?
Oui
Non
Quel mode d'investissement choisir ?
Entreprise totalement exportatrices
Facteurs structurels : taille et expérience de
l'entreprise
Choix du mode de présence, par l'investissement
2 them assumptions of research
Assumption n°1 : The size of
the partners has a positive effect on the level of investment ;
Assumption n°2 : The size
of the partners has a positive effect on the level of control
Assumption n°3 : The
experiment of the partners has a positive effect on the level of investment
Assumption n°4 : The
experiment of the partners has a positive effect on the level of control.
Section 2 :
Population of the study
In order to answer the formulated problems, it was necessary
for us to choose a sample of companies to which one will try to apply a certain
scientific step, tool for validation of the assumptions.

One notices according to the diagram so above that 2142
companies with foreign participation are established in Tunisia in the
industrial sector including 1731 completely exporting and 411 partially
exporting (see appendix n°1).
The population of our research is composed of companies with
participation foreign and operative according to the mode « not
completely exporting », and that for all the Tunisian industrial
sector (see appendix n°2).
The difference in term of a number between our base and the
statistics provided by the API one are due to the shift of time since our base
is more recent than the statistics.
To belong to our population the company must meet the
following conditions :
- To be a company with foreign participation ;
- To operate according to the mode : « not
completely exporting » ;
- To operate in the industrial sector.
Section 3 :
Base data
We are interested in this research to study a data base
composed by the partially exporting companies with foreign participation
established in Tunisia.
This list is provided by two bases : on the one hand with
the meadows of the Agency of Promotion of Industry (API), on the other hand
with close to the official Web site the API one
The list provided by the API one comprises a set of data on
the companies with knowing :
it corporate name ;
- The address ;
- Telephone number, fax ;
- Activity, Branch of industry ;
- Person in charge ;
- A Number of employment ;
it rate of foreign participation ;
it capital ;
Missing information which is provided by the site of Internet
the API one is :
them nationalities of the foreign participants ;
it creation date of the company
We will try to check our assumptions by the analysis of these
data.
We will try to explain, on the one hand, the relation between
the size of the company and the choice of the mode of presence by the variables
capital and a number of employees and on the other hand, the influence of the
experiment of the company on the choice of the mode of presence by the variable
year of presence.
The variable nationality facilitates the interpretation of the
countries present to us on the Tunisian territory.
Section 4 :
Statistical tools
The techniques of analysis of data that we propose to use are
the descriptive method, the tri dish, the cross sorting and the test of Khi
2.
1 it descriptive method
The principal stage of the descriptive method is that of the
statistical observation, it consists with a transcription of the part of the
reality in which one is interested in a number of data to which the analysis
will relate.
Several approaches are possible ;
seek it of a synthesis by the image which means translation of
the information quantified in the form of graphs ;
seek it of a synthesis by parameters of central tendency and
of dispersion, these parameters are not the same ones if one is interested in a
qualitative character (the average, the median and mode), or if one is
interested in a quantitative character (the interquartile interval, the
variance and the standard deviation).
2 them flat sorting (or simple
sorting)
The simple sorting consists in comparing the answers
concerning a question according to various possible methods', which amounts
revealing the absolute and relative frequencies for each variable on each
method.
3 them cross sorting
The cross sorting aims to cross the variables two to two with
an aim of determining the existence or not significant association between
them, or them and the individuals.
This level it should be noted that the validity of identified
associations was the subject of the statistical tests of significance
(Khi-deux). Thus several crossings can be carried out.
4 it test of Khi-deux
To supplement and validate classifications carried out, one
can plan for the cross sorting the test of Khi-deux, it consists in comparing a
distribution observed with a theoretical distribution.
Indeed, the ÷2 observed is calculated in the following
way :

With :
fij : Frequency observed in the iéme line and the
jéme column
Fij : Theoretical frequency in the iéme line and
the jéme column
m : A number of lines
N : A number of columns
· In our analysis the theoretical ÷2 is in the table
of distribution according to the probability of error á=10% and numbers
it degree of freedom = (M-1) X (n-1). It should be noted that when ÷
² 0>? ² T, there exists a relation between
the two variables. In the contrary case, the two variables in questions are
independent.
Chapter II :
Analyze secondary data
In this chapter, we are interested in the checking of the
validity of our assumptions of research which we will test on our already
selected population.
To achieve our goal one will use three methods ; analysis
of the frequencies, factorial analysis and analysis of Khi two.
Section 1 :
Analyze frequencies
The analysis will relate to the list provided by the API one,
we carry out an analysis of the frequencies of the variables : rate of
participation, nationality, capital of the company, numbers employees and years
of presence.
1-rate of foreign participation

One notices according to this graph that 27.5% of the total of
the companies with foreign participation and partially exporters exert a level
of very high control, 23.7% of the companies have a level of more or less
raised control, 23% exert a level of control realizing low whereas 25.8% of the
companies have a level of very low control (less than 25%) (see appendix
n°3).
2-nationality

Our population is made up of five categories of group of
country according to their frequencies ;
One can notice that France at the highest frequency with
39.9%. This strong presence on our territory can be explained by the very old
bonds between the two countries and the bringing together in term of culture
and geographical distance.
In second plan, one finds Italy with 25.1% whose majority of
these companies are in the sector of textile and of leather, Switzerland and
the category «others» which includes/understands Spain, the USA,
Germany, Belgium... hold almost the same share on the Tunisian market with
respectively 8.6% and 8.2%. Finally the Arab countries occupy a good place in
the investments in Tunisia with 18.2% (see appendix n°3).
3-capital of the company

The variable « capital of the company » is
divided into five intervals, the majority of the companies have a capital
higher than 700000DT what shows the presence of the companies of big sizes in
Tunisia (54.3%), the companies which have a capital between 50000 and 150000DT
and 150000 and 400000DT account for 15.8% and 16.2% respectively, and finally
those of which the capital lower than 50000 DT (6.5%) and between 400000 and
700000DT (7.2%) represent the least significant part (see appendix
n°3).
4-number of employees

One can notice dice the beginning that the companies belonging
to our population were used to create a very significant number of stations as
employment considering the number of these companies and the share of those of
big sizes among them.
It should be noted that 35.1% of the companies engage more
than 80 employees what returns to the size of the company and in second
position 28.5% of the companies employ only less than 20 employees what does
not neglect the importance of small and medium-sized companies in Tunisia. The
third place is reserved for those which offer between 20 and 40 working
stations (18.9%), then 12.7% engaging between 40 and 60 employment and in last
position a small share of the companies is those which between 60 and 80 paid
(4.8%) (see appendix n°3).
5-years of presence

The variable « Years of presence »
reflects the experiment of the company in the field of the investments. The
companies of our study are in all the intervals in a way nonproportional.
The companies having least experience (less than 5 years of
presence on the Tunisian market) occupy the great place with 30.9%, then those
pertaining to the second interval (between 5 and 10 years) with 23.4%. 21.3% of
the companies have a long experiment since they have existed on the market for
more than 20 years.
In the last positions companies having experience between 10
and 15 years (16.5%) and those between 15 and 20 years (7.9%) (see appendix
n°3).
Section 2 :
Analyze factorial
The factorial analysis is a geometrical principle making it
possible automatically to convert a table of figures into synthetic images,
which release the principal structures of them. The first stage consists in
translating the table in a space in the shape of a group of dots, the second
stage acts to seek to visualize the clouds obtained on best possible plane
projections, one thus chooses, best projection to form the factorial axes.
The variable points all are in this cloud materialize well all
the phenomena of correlation between the variables of the table.
Our research releases the following results ;

It is noticed that KMO = 0.638 >0.6 thus these items can
translate the phenomenon to be studied.
While referring in the table of original variance (see
appendix n°5) one retained two axes according to the criterion eigenvalue
> 1, the first axis explains 40.428% of the original variance of the sample
and the second axis explains 21.706% of the original variance.
The system of axes formed explains 62.133% of the original
variance.
The graph shows well that the first two axes are those whose
eigenvalue is higher than 1 and thus they form the factorial design.

It is noticed that the first axis is formed by the number of
employment with 84.5% and the authorized capital with 81% whereas the second
axis represents nationality with a factorial contribution of 89.1%.
The rate of participation can improve, therefore one carries
out a rotation varimax to optimize the result and to seek a better positioning
of the variables around the axes.

After rotation, one notices that the year of presence can also
contribute to form the first axis since its factorial contribution is higher
than 50% (67.1%), in the same way for the rate of participation which can in
its turn form the second axis with a coefficient of structure = 55%.
Thus the first axis expresses the size and the experiment of
the company which are the structural factors and the second axis expresses in
its turn the level of control and nationality.

According to this table one can conclude that the two axes are
not correlated (see appendix n°5).
Section 3 :
Analyze of Khi two
1 it relation between the nationality and the mode
of establishment

The test of ÷2 shows well the existence of a relation
between the variable nationality and the rate of foreign participation since
÷2observ? (24.148) > ÷2tabul? (6.304) to 12 degrees of freedom and
when á =10% thus the two variables are dependant (see appendix
n°6).
2 it relation between the size of the company and
the mode of establishment
2.1 it relation between the capital of the company
and the mode of presence.

According to the result of the test of ÷2 one
notices that ÷2observ? (with 12 degrees of freedom) is 30.823 whereas
÷2tabul? is only 6.304 with the threshold of á =10%, one thus finds
that ÷2observ? higher than one is ÷2tabul? then rejects H0 (the two
variables are independent) and one accepts H1 our assumption of research which
means the existence of relation between the two studied variables (see appendix
n°6).
2.2 it relation between the number of employees and
the mode of presence

One notices that ÷2observ? (22.494) > ÷2theoric
(6.304) to 12 degrees of freedom thus one rejects H0 (not relation between two
variables), which leads us to conclude that there is a connection between the
number of employees and the mode of presence, therefore that confirms our
assumption of research (see appendix n°6).
3 it relation between the number of years of
presence and the mode of establishment

According to table Ci above one notices that ÷2observ?
who is 16.976 is higher than ÷2theoric which is 6.304 with the threshold
of á =10% and with 12 degrees of freedom then one rejects the H0
assumption and one accepts H1, that confirms our assumption of research which
supposes that there is a relation between the experiment (calculated by the
number of years of presence) and the choice of the mode of presence which
expresses at the same time the level of control and the level of investment
(calculated by the rate of foreign participation) (see appendix n°6).
Synthesis
At the time of this empirical study we could confirm our
assumptions of research by an analysis of the frequencies, a factorial analysis
and an analysis of Khi two.
The size of the company that we studied through the variables
capital and a number of employees strongly explains the selected mode and
influences in great part the level of control held by the company.
The rate of foreign participation reflects the capital invests
and the level of control, one noticed that there is a strong relation between
control and the TPE.
The experiment of the company measured by the number of years
of presence expresses the training obtained in the field of the IDE and which
influences the behavior of the choice of the mode of presence.
General conclusion
The internationalization of the companies, this phenomenon
which developed well in the last decades, presents several modes of development
for the companies. This research aims to determine these various modes and to
especially explain the choice of the mode of presence by the IDE while being
based on two selection criteria which are the size and the experiment of the
company.
The foreign direct investment was often analyzed like a
homogeneous unit. We analyzed it in this study like a category of modes of
presence forming the minority partnership, partnership 50/50, the majority
partnership and the plate venture. However, each mode among them supposes a
behavior different from that of another mode.
For this purpose, one tried to check if there exists or not a
differentiation between the behaviors of establishment of the foreign investors
in Tunisia.
In the theoretical part, we initially tried to collect the
lesson provided by the various disciplines which were interested in this
phenomenon through authors who were distinguished by their contributions and by
synthesizing the literature in this field knowing that this work is very many
and bearing on aspects different from the same subject. In the second place, we
tried to validate certain aspects of the results of the theory in this
field.
However we tried to cover the subject while being based on two
aspects (size and experiment of the partners) more than the other aspects of
the choice of the mode of presence.
Implication of research
Research in this field makes it possible to the investors to
better analyze the market and the environment before generally choosing the
mode of presence by the investment bus, the degree of engagement should be
related to the objectives of the investor on the market aimed and not only to
the will to hold a level of high control.
Limits of research
Our research present, certainly, several limits which can be
dependant ;
- With the significant number of factors being able to
intervene in the choice of the mode of presence by the investment, that it was
difficult to us to integrate them all in the same study and especially to
validate their influence, for that we chose those which appear to us most
operational.
- Our study would have gained in rigor if we had added another
variable which explains the experiment of the company beside the number of
years of presence to knowing the training acquired in the field of the IDE.
- With the selected population since the Tunisian framework
can not be in conformity with the international framework.
Future ways of research
The prospects for research are vast in this field. Indeed, we
treated in this research only one aspect of the problem.
It would be interesting to carry out a time series to follow
the evolution of behavior of the foreign investors.
Or to widen the fields of this research in order to carry out
studies on the hotel sector or the sector of the agriculture which can release
from the characteristics specific to them.
Another possibility would be to compare between the behavior
of the completely exporting companies and that of the partially exporting
companies in the choice of the mode of presence.
The future studies can be interested in the other modes of
presence other than by the IDE with knowing the frankness, subcontracting...
while being based on the behavior of the investors or the level of engagement.
Bibliography
Articles:
1. AGARWAL S &S NR RAMAZWAMI (1992) « Choice off
Foreign Market Entry Mode: Impact off ownership, Hiring and
Internationalization Factors "
2. ANDESON E & H GATIGNON « Modes off Foreign
Entry; translation costs analysis and proposals " Newspaper off International
Business Studies, Fall 1986
3. BOUYEURE C (1993) : « The international
investment », PUF, `Which I know ? ', 1256, p128
4. SUCKERS R. (1982) : « Multinational
Enterprise and economic analysis » Cambridge university near.
5. DAVID J P (2002) : « Internationalization of
SME : a grid of analysis », the Expansion Review Management,
p82
6. DAVIDSON & MCFETRIDGE (1985) « Keys
characteristics in the choice off international technology transfer mode " 16
Summer 5-22
7. DESREUMAUX A (1999) :
« Internationalization », in Encyclopedia of management and
management, under the direction of R Duff, pp522-524
8. DUSSAUGE P & B GARRETTE (1997) « To
anticipate the consequences of strategic alliances », Re-examined
French of Management
9. ERRAMILI MR. K &C P ROA : « Choice off
foreign market entry modes by service firms : role off market knowledge "
(30), p 135-149
10. FOLTA T B (1998) : « Governance and
Uncertainty: the trade-off between administrative control and
commitment », Strategic Management Newspaper, (19), pp1007-1028
11. GUMS B CASSERES (2001) : « Strategy,
keystone of alliances », Echoes
12. HAEHNSEN E & E KAN (1996) :
« Subcontracting in change », Book Industries, 21,
pp11-21
13. HAIYANG C & Y HU MICHAEL (2002): «Year analysis
off determining off entry mode and its impact one performance»,
International off Business Review 11, pp193-210
14. HEMANT M (2000) « Configuration off
international joint venture », International Management Review, (40)
p 107-140
15. HUGONNIER B (1997) : « Multinational
corporations », in Encyclopedia of management, under the direction of
Y Simon and P Joffre, pp1115-1135
16. JOLLY, D (1995) « To manage a technological
partnership », Expansion Review Management
17. KOENIG G (1994) « The organisational
training » location of the places, French Review of Management
18. MAYRHOFFER U & R O FABRICE (1999):
« Management of uncertainty and influence of diversification and
nationality on the forms of bringing together », Université
Robert Schuman Strasbourg3- Finances Control Strategy 4 (2), pp135-156
19. MUCCHIELLI J L (1992) : « Determinants of
the delocalization and multinational firms » Re-examined economic, 4
(43), pp1-27
20. RAMUDHIN A & PLEFRANÇOIS & S OF LOVES &
B MONTREUIL (1996) : « With decision support system for
operations scheduling in distributed environment ", Re-examined systems of
decision, Hermès 1-2 (5)
21. VERNON R. (1979) : « The product cycle
hypothesis in A new international environment », Oxford Bulletin off
economics and statistics 41, pp255-267
22. WERDEN, G (1998) « Antitrust Analysis off Joined
Ventures: Year Overview », Antitrust Law Newspaper, (66)
23. WICKHAM S.P (1989) : « Direct investments
and foreign subsidiary companies through European industrial space »,
Economy applied, Review published by the ISMEA Paris and the university presses
of Grenoble, divide into volumes XLII, 4, pp87-112
Works :
1. ALAIN NR & PHILIPPE V & MICHEL W
« Prospects in strategic management », Volume II
(1994-1995)
2. ANDREFF W « Multinationals »,
Edition : the discovery, Paris (1987)
3. ANDREFF W « Total multinationals »,
Edition the discovery Paris (1996)
4. DE LEERSHNYDER J M «International Marketing»,
1ère Edition, Dalloz (1982)
5. DUSSAUGE P & RAMANANTSOA B « Technology and
strategy of company » McGraw-Hill (1987)
6. GARRETTE B & DUSSAUGE P « Strategies of
alliance », Editions of organization (1995)
7. HUGONNIER B « Direct investment, international
co-operation and multinational corporations » Economica, Paris
(1984)
8. JACQUEMIN A « International and multinational
strategic behavior «, Kyklos, 4 (1989)
9. JOFFRE P « To include/understand the
universalization of the company », Edition Economica (1994)
10. LANGEFELD- W K « The Joint international
ventures » GLN Jolly Edition (1992)
11. LANGEFELD W.K « The Ventures Joint
International », Cologne, translation and adaptation : Andre
Garcia (1992)
12. LIBBEY J « The entrepreneuriat in
French-speaking Africa », Editions AUPELF-UREF, (1990)
13. MICHALET C « World capitalism », 2nd
Edition, PUF (1985)
14. MUCCHIELLI J.M « Multinational firms,
perspective changes and news », Paris, Edition Economica (1985)
15. MUCCHIELLI J.M « Multinational enterprises,
International investments and transfers off technology : the elements off
year integrated approach » Paris, Edition Economica (1987)
16. TO CARRY M «The off competitive advantage
nation», London, Macmillan (1990)
Theses and memories :
1. GUÉDON S & MÉLOU C (2002):
« The joint ventures : general characteristics and
typology », OF the Finance of Company, University of Rennes
2. LAHIMER NR (2003) : « Determining factors of
the delocalization : Comparative study enters Asia and Africa »
Dauphine Paris University
3. WACHEUX F (1993) : « Organisational
processes and sets of actors to work in alliances between firms, exploratory
Study in the Building industry and Public works », thesis of
Doctorate, Dauphine Paris University
4. ZMERLI K (1998) : « Determinants of the
choice of the mode of presence abroad : case of presence by the investment
in Tunisia », Memory of DEA, Higher Institute of Management,
university of Tunis III
Sites of Internet :
1.
www.tunisieindustrie.nat.tn
2.
www.enstimac.fr/manif/gi-albi-97/LIENBD/PapFinal/Publis/3B484285.pdf
3.
www.robic.com/publications/Pdf/130-HGR.pdf
4.
www.afc-cca.com/congres2001/textespdf/Martinez.pdf
5. www.juriscope.org
Appendices
List appendices
APPENDIX N°1 :
Statistics on the companies with foreign participation
APPENDIX N°2 :
Lists of the companies with foreign participation and
partially exporters
APPENDIX N°3 :
Simple sorting
A number of individuals 291
APPENDIX N°4 :
Cross sorting
A number of individuals 291
APPENDIX N°5 :
Analyze factorial
APPENDIX N°6 :
Analyze of Khi two
Appendix n°1 :
Statistics on the companies with foreign
participation
Appendix n°2 :
Lists of the companies with foreign participation
and partially exporters
Appendix n°3 :
Simple sorting
A number of individuals 291
Appendix n°4 :
Cross sorting
A number of individuals 291
Appendix n°5 :
Analyze factorial
Appendix n°6 :
Analyze of Khi two
Contents
General introduction 1
PART 1 : THEORETICAL PART 4
CHAPTER I : The
internationalization of the companies 5
Section 1 : Definition and factors of
internationalization 5
1-definitions 5
2 them factors of internationalization 7
Section 2 : Advantages and
consequences of internationalization 8
1 them advantages 8
Competitive 1.1-advantages of the firms and comparative
advantages of the countries 8
Strategic 1.2-advantages 9
2 them consequences 10
2.1-on the country of origin 10
2.2-on the host country 10
Section 3 : Strategies of
internationalization 11
1 them strategies of opening to several dimensions
12
1.1 them strategies of contractual presence 12
to it frankness has 12
B it transfer of license 13
C it subcontracting 14
D them contracts of management 14
1.2 them strategies of presence per Direct Investment abroad
15
2 it search for co-operation 16
2.1-reports 16
2.2-Pourquoi to tie a co-operation? 17
2.3 it co-operation : Risky strategy or gaining
bet ? 18
2.4- the Joint Venture : a rational choice ! 19
CHAPTER II : The Joint Venture : a
form of cooperation 21
Section 1 :
Definitions and characteristic of the joint venture
21
1-definitions 21
2-characteristics of the joint venture 23
Historical 2.1-outline 23
a- Joint ventures and multinationalisation 23
b- Joint ventures and competition 24
2.2 them reasons to be 24
to it universalization has 25
b- Acceleration of the technological change 25
c- Obstacles with the trade 26
2.3-advantages and disadvantages 26
A-advantages 26
b- Disadvantages 27
Section 2 : Degree of
internationalization 28
1 them methods of establishment 28
2 it level of investment and control per mode of joint
venture 29
Section 3: Specific factors of the joint
ventures 31
1 cuts it 31
1.1 cuts it partners 31
1.2 cuts it market 32
2-L' experiment 33
2.1-L' international experiment 33
2.2 it role of the experiment in the choice of the mode of
presence 35
PART 2 : EMPIRICAL PART 36
CHAPTER I : Methodology of
research 37
Section 1 : Identification and
operationalisation of the problem 37
1-recall of the problems 37
2 them assumptions of research 39
Section 2 : Population of the study
39
Section 3 : Base data
40
Section 4 : Statistical tools
41
1 it descriptive method 42
2 them flat sorting (or simple sorting) 42
3 them cross sorting 42
4 it test of Khi-deux 42
CHAPTER II : Analyze
secondary data 44
Section 1 : Analyze frequencies
44
1-rate of foreign participation 44
2-nationality 45
3-capital of the company 46
4-number of employees 46
5-years of presence 47
Section 2 : Analyze factorial
48
Section 3 : Analyze of Khi two
50
1 it relation between the nationality and the mode of
establishment 50
2 it relation between the size of the company and the
mode of establishment 51
2.1 it relation between the capital of the company and the
mode of presence 51
2.2 it relation between the number of employees and the mode
of presence 51
3 it relation between the number of years of presence
and the mode
of establishment 52
General conclusion 53
Bibliography 56
Appendices 59
Dedications
I dedicate this work
With my dear parents
Who helped me materially and morally
With my brothers and my sisters
With my dear friends Aida and
Karima
With my Moujib colleague
And with all my family.
Ines
Dedications
I dedicate this modest work
With my expensive obvious,
With my brother and my sisters
who always supported me.
With my grandmother that god
blessed
All those which I like and god knows that they are
numerous
All very expensive beings in my
hearts
With my colleague of always Ines
And with the beautiful life which forever does not betray
me.
Moujib
Thanks
We make a point of expressing our sharp thanks and
our gratitude with our professor Mlle Zmerli Karima
who agreed to agree to direct this
work.
We are very grateful to him of its support and its
invaluable councils.
Synopsis
General introduction 1
PART 1 : THEORETICAL PART 4
CHAPTER I : The
internationalization of the companies 5
Section 1 : Definition and factors of
internationalization 5
Section 2 : Advantages and
consequences of internationalization 8
Section 3 : Strategies of
internationalization 11
CHAPTER II : The Joint Venture : a
form of cooperation 21
Section 1 :
Definitions and characteristics 21
Section 2 : Degree of
internationalization 28
Section 3: Specific factors of the joint
ventures 31
PART 2 : EMPIRICAL PART 36
CHAPTER I : Methodology of
research 37
Section 1 : Identification and
operationalisation of the problem 37
Section 2 : Population of the study
39
Section 3 : Base data
40
Section 4 : Statistical tools
41
CHAPTER II : Analyze
secondary data 44
Section 1 : Analyze frequencies
44
Section 2 : Analyze factorial
48
Section 3 : Analyze of Khi two
50
General conclusion 53
Bibliography 56
Appendices 59
University of the Center
And Economic Management Faculty of Science of
Mahdia
Memory of end of studies
for obtaining the Control
in Management
The influence of the factors structural on the choice
of the mode of presence
Worked out by
|
Framed by
|
Ines Ben Njima
Moujib Errahmen Ismaïli
|
Miss Karima Zmerli
|
Academic year : 2003- 2004
* 1 Andreff W
(1987) : « Multinationals », Edition : the
discovery
* 2 Vernon R. (1979) :
« The product cycle hypothesis in A new international
environment », Oxford Bulletin off economics and statistics
41, pp255-267
* 3 Suckers R. (1982) :
« Multinational Enterprise and economic analysis »
Cambridge university near.
* 4 Hugonnier B (1984)
: « Direct investment, international co-operation and multinational
corporations » Economica
Hugonnier B (1997) : « Multinational
corporations », in Encyclopedia of management, under the direction
of Y Simon and P Joffre, pp1115-1135
* 5 Michalet C. (1985)
: « World capitalism », 2nd Edition, PUF.
Andreff W. (1996) : « Total
multinationals », Edition the discovery
* 6 Desreumaux A (1999)
: « Internationalization », in Encyclopedia of management
and management, under the direction of R Duff, pp522-524
* 7 David J P (2002) :
« Internationalization of SME : a grid of analysis
», the Expansion Review Management, June 2002, p82
* 8 Mucchielli J L (July
1992) : « Determinants of the delocalization and multinational
firms » Re-examined economic, flight 43, N° 4.
* 9 Lahimer NR (2003) :
Memory « Determining factors of the delocalization :
Comparative study enters Asia and Africa » Dauphine Paris
University
* 10 Mucchielli J L
(1992) COp-cit
* 11 Mucchielli J L
(1985) : « Multinational firms, perspective changes and
news », Paris, Economica Edition
- Mucchielli J L (1987) : « Multinational
enterprises, International investments and transfers off technology : the
elements off year integrated approach » Paris, Economica Edition
- To carry M (1990): «The competitive advantage off
nation», London, Macmillan
* 12 Jacquemin A
(1989) : « International and multinational strategic behavior
«, Kyklos, 4
* 13 Mucchielli J L
(1992) COp-cit
* 14 idem
* 15 Zmerli K (1998) :
« Determinants of the choice of the mode of presence abroad :
case of presence by the investment in Tunisia », Memory of DEA,
Higher Institute of Management, university of Tunis III
* 16 Mayrhoffer U &
Fabrice R O (1999): « Management of uncertainty and influence of
diversification and nationality on the forms of bringing together »,
Université Robert Schuman Strasbourg3- Finances Control Strategy
volume2, N°4, pp135-156
* 17 Guédon S &
Mélou C, memory of research : « The Joint Venture
: General characteristics and Typologies », OF the Finance of
company (October 2002)
* 18 Zmerli K (1998),
COp-cit
* 19 French
federation of Franchising
* 20 Mendez M & Lehnisch
J P (1989) : «How to make a success of of frankness »,
Bordered, Paris
* 21 Langefeld W K (1992):
« The Joint international ventures » GLN Jolly Edition
* 22 The French law of
December 31, 1975 (www.juriscope.org)
* 23 Haehnsen E & Kan E
(1996) : « Subcontracting in change », Book
Industries, N°21, pp11-21
* 24 Garrette B &
Dussauge P (1995) : « Strategies of alliance »,
Editions of organization
* 25 De Leershnyder J M
(1982): «International Marketing», 1ère Edition, Dalloz
* 26 Zmerli K (1998)
COp-cit
* 27 Wickham S.P
(1989) : « Direct investments and foreign subsidiary companies
through European industrial space », Economy applied, Review
published by the ISMEA Paris and the university presses of Grenoble, divide
into volumes XLII, N°4, pp87-112
* 28 Joffre P (1994) :
« To include/understand the universalization of the company
», Economica Edition
* 29 Bouyeure C (1993)
: « The international investment », PUF, `Which I
know ? ', N°1256, p128
* 30 Folta T B (1998)
: « Governance and Uncertainty: the trade-off between administrative
control and commitment », Strategic Management Newspaper, flight 19,
p1007-1028
* 31 Ramudhin A &
Lefrançois P & S Of Loves & Montreuil B (1996) :
« With decision support system for operations scheduling in
distributed environment ", Re-examined systems of decision, flight 5,
N°1-2, Hermès
* 32 Wacheux F (1993)
: « Organisational processes and sets of actors to work in alliances
between firms, exploratory Study in the Building industry and Public
works », thesis of Doctorate, Dauphine Paris University
* 33 Dussauge P
& Garrette B (1997) « To anticipate the consequences of
strategic alliances », Re-examined French of Management, June, July,
August
* 34 Casseres gums, B
(2001) : « Strategy, keystone of alliances
», Echoes, of the 21/03/01
* 35 Langefeld W K
(1992) : « The Ventures Joint International »,
Cologne, translation and adaptation : Andre Garcia
* 36 Jolly D (1995)
« To manage a technological partnership », Expansion
Review Management, June 1995.
* 37 Libbey J (1990) the
entrepreneuriat in French-speaking Africa, Editions AUPELF-UREF, 1990.
* 38 Werden G (1998).
« Antitrust Analysis off Joined Ventures: Year Overview
», Antitrust Law Newspaper, vol. 66,
* 39 Alain NR & Philippe
V & Michel W : « Prospects in strategic management
», Volume II, 1994-1995
* 40 Alain NR & Philippe
V & Michel W (1994-1995) COp-cit
* 41 Garrette, B &
Dussauge, P (1995) COp-cit
* 42 Dussauge, P &
Ramanantsoa, B (1987) « Technology and strategy of company,
McGraw-Hill
* 43 Langefeld W K (1992)
COp-cit
*
44Guédon S & Mélou C (2002),
COp-cit
* 45 Longefeld W K (1992)
COp-cit
* 46 Davidson &
Mcfetridge (1985) « Keys characteristics in the choice off
international technology transfer mode " 16 Summer 5-22
* 47 Joffre P (1994)
COp-cit
* 48 Hemant M
(2000) : « Configuration off international joint venture
», International Management Review, flight 40, 2000/2, p
107-140
* 49 Agarwal S &
Ramazwami S NR: « Choice off Foreign Market Entry Mode: Impact off
ownership, Hiring and Internationalization Factors ", First Quarter 1992, p
1-27
* 50 Davidson &
Mcfetridge (1985) COp-cit
* 51 Agarwal S &
Ramazwami S NR (1992) COp-cit
* 52 Andeson E &
Gatignon H: « Modes off Foreign Entry; translation costs analysis
and proposals " Newspaper off International Business Studies, Fall 1986
* 53 Haiyang C & Michael
Y HU (2002): «Year analysis off determining off entry mode and its impact
one performance», International off Business Review 11, pp193-210
* 54 Zmerli K (1998)
COp-cit
* 55 Koenig G :
« The organisational training » location of the places,
French Review of Management, January-February 1994
* 56 Zmerli K (1998)
COp-cit
* 57
idem
* 58 City by Erramili MR. K
& Roa C P : « Choice off foreign market entry modes by
service firms : role off market knowledge " flight 30, p 135-149
|